Minnesota DFLers have a lot of reasons to be incredibly excited this cycle. Franken’s running a legitimately refreshing and politically rejuvenating campaign; Congressman Tim Walz is running a tremendous campaign; it looks like we’re going to have a candidate in the 6th that’s actually a good fit for the district; we have a guy in the 2nd that, on paper, has a real shot at Kline; and the 3rd CD is in play for the first time in, well, forever. This is fun, this is exciting, this is great for party building, but let’s not get carried away because one thing it won’t be is easy.
I think there are a small selection of DFLers who are reading about all the excitement and getting wrapped up in the legitimate enthusiasm of so many in the party and thinking that this is going to be a landslide year for us; it’s not. Look, everyone should be excited, but no one should kid themselves about the difficult road ahead of us; if we delude ourselves into thinking we’ll win all of these no problem, we’ll lose.
I don’t mean to be a party-pooper, in fact I’ll be an enthusiastic cheer-leader for all these guys over the next 6+ months, but let’s take a look at the odds for a sec. I’ll get the easier analysis out of the way first: Walz has a tough race ahead and he needs the vigilant help of activists, but this is his race to lose and Davis doesn’t pose a significant challenge. Franken and Coleman are at 50/50 and it’s anyone’s game; this race is going to be nuts but I think people’s expectations here are grounded and reasonable.
Note: In the below numbers I’m not predicting the end vote, I’m just assessing odds; the two are slightly different in my mind. I don’t mean, for example, that the vote in the 2nd is going to break 60/40 in November.

The 2nd, 3rd, and 6th are all tough, tough races for us, however. Sarvi is an excellent match for the district and serves as an amazing contrast to Kline given their shared military experience, but without more money, he’s sunk. Kline’s been there forever, he has a machine built, and he has enough money to weather the dry-spell the GOP’s having nationally in fundraising this year; in short, he’s a huge tree to topple. Sarvi has the skills, he has the resume, but now he needs the money; in a really big way. Odds: 60/40 for Kline.

The 6th, I think, is actually an even longer shot for us. If El had been the candidate in 2006, Bachmann might be unemployed right now, but she isn’t, she’s in Congress. And, for whatever reason, she resonates very well in the 6th and has tons of money right now. El’s a great fit for this district, but his chances are much slimmer this cycle than they would have been in ‘06. That being said, I can’t imagine a better candidate for the district and I can’t imagine us having this good of a shot at the district until it’s redistricted. Odds: 65/35 for Bachmann.

And, finally, the 3rd. It seems as though there are some people who think that the 3rd is ours to lose and I want to state for the record that this is absolutely ludicrous. To be sure we have a real shot at this seat for the first time, but the odds have never been in our favor. This is still a Republican leaning district and the biggest GOP donors in the state are all within its boundaries. And Ramstad will still be a force in this district and he’ll be campaigning for Paulsen–a huge advantage. Madia or Bonoff, this was and has always been a very steep hill to climb. That being said, I think this is our best pick-up chance this cycle. Madia has a great story to tell, he’s going to raise tons of cash, and Obama being on the ticket is going to mobilize a lot of suburbanites to vote Democratic. Odds: 55/45 for Paulsen.
Now, all of the above (especially my “odds” numbers) should be taken with a large grain of salt, but I felt the need to write something sobering lest our exuberance gets carried away. We have the best slate of candidates for these districts that we could ask for, but it’s going to take tons of elbow grease and cash to get it done. So, don’t let anyone rest on their laurels; let’s get out there and beat the odds.
People are Shouting