August 31st, 2010
jeff-rosenberg

Poll shows gubernatorial race much tighter, but is it accurate?

According to a new MPR/Humphrey Institute poll, the race is now deadlocked. To some extent, the race was always going to tighten up once all of the candidates firmed up. On the other hand, a significant amount of the change can be attributed to the poll’s methodology.

Here are the poll’s results, for what they’re worth:

Mark Dayton: 34%
Tom Emmer: 34%
Tom Horner: 13%
Undecided: 19%

Now, what are the issues with the poll? First of all, it was a somewhat small sample of 750 people, with an estimated margin of error of 5.3 percentage points. That means one candidate could have as much as a 10-point lead, even if that is fairly unlikely. Even worse is the methodology: The poll was based on a “landline, random-digit dial survey.”

Landline? Are you kidding me? I wonder how many younger voters were missed. Not having a landline, I could never have been contacted for this poll.

Maybe that helps to account for the poll’s likely-voter model:

Republican: 46%
Democrat: 41%
Independent: 13%

You’ll have to excuse me if I don’t buy that. The oversampling of Republicans is yet another reason to suspect that this poll overstates the extent to which the race has actually narrowed.

Ultimately, this is just a single poll, and time will tell whether it’s an outlier. I suspect its broad finding — the race narrowing — is probably accurate. But I also suspect that future polls will continue to show a Dayton lead, just a somewhat smaller one.

COMMENT POLICY

MNpublius welcomes your comments. We do not censor comments, but we do reserve the right to moderate comments or block users. We will not block users because of their political views, but we may take action against repeated personal attacks or abusive language. Because this is an open forum, the comments below should not be assumed to represent the views of MNpublius or its authors.